Peter Henderson
SAN FRANCISCO: From computers that could steer airliners away from
skyscrapers to face-recognition devices already used to spot card counters in
casinos, technology could provide ways to make the skies safer, but at a cost,
experts said.
Current technology, which focuses on weapons searches, was bested by
terrorists armed with knives and box cutters who crashed hijacked planes into
the World Trade Center and the Pentagon this week. To prevent this, new security
systems could be buttressed with devices that look for terrorists before
boarding and ones that keep the plane safe, experts said.
Autopilots could be linked to terrain warning systems, which the Federal
Aviation Administration already requires in new US aircraft, that show pilots
what is below and recognize major landmark buildings, for instance.
"It's only a small step to take that, link it into the flight control
system, and voila, you have something that you can stop things flying into
buildings," said Ian Sheppard, of British airline consultant Air Claims.
But putting that technological fix into service would require extensive
testing and raise questions about taking control from pilots, said Ron Crotty, a
spokesman for Honeywell International Inc., which makes the terrain systems.
"Technically it is possible," he said. But it would take expensive
certification as well as modification of the systems, which sell for around
$70,000. "Every time you take control of the plane away from the pilot, it
is a major problem," Crotty said.
FAA spokesman Les Dorr said his agency took a different approach: "We
really don't think that that sort of technology would be the solution to the
hijacking issue. Where technology can be brought to bear is keeping those kinds
of individuals and any weapons off the aircraft."
The FAA is already rolling out new technology, including million-dollar,
three-dimensional scanners that probe checked baggage for bombs, comparing the
density of items inside to those of explosives. The scanners are made by
InVision Technologies, Inc., a security device maker based in Newark, Calif.
Airports single out suitcases for scrutiny with an FAA computer system that
winnows out better-known passengers. Experts say that probably means allowing
frequent flyers to pass, for instance, although the FAA declined to give
details.
New X-ray machines for carry-on luggage also will be phased in over the next
year, in which software will randomly generate images of fake weapons to keep
security staff who watch machines on their toes, the FAA said.
"To stay in business they are going to have to screeners got that meet
our standards," FAA spokeswoman Rebecca Trexler said.
The new machines will tell workers when they've caught fakes without
requiring packages to be opened and allow the FAA to monitor how contract
security firms are performing. The agency is seeking other ways to improve
security as well, Trexler said.
The augmented X-ray machine addresses a main concern - the low level of
training for many airport workers. "They can either work for McDonald's or
be screeners," said Bob Monetti, an air security advocate whose son died on
Pan Am flight 103, which exploded in December 1998 over Lockerbie, Scotland.
Monetti has since become a member of the FAA's Aviation Security Advisory
Committee. Screeners face a tougher task now that the FAA has banned knives in
the aftermath of the World Trade Center attacks.
"Everybody carries a little pocket knife," Monetti said. "To
say we will not allow anybody to carry one is somewhere between really silly and
unenforceable."
A solution would be to check the people in addition to what they are
carrying, said Monetti and Francois Mesqui, chief technology officer of InVision.
"If it is true that you could hijack a plane with a small knife, there
must be another security feature that we are using to make sure that passengers
going on a plane (are) offering a certain guarantee, by themselves, that they
are not dangerous people," he said.
Evening the odds
Casinos have already found a way to even the odds in their business. More than
100 casinos - and two European airports - have bought face recognition systems
from Littleton, Mass.-based Viisage Technology, Inc.
"We use it to filter players and suspicious people," said Derk
Boss, who uses the system to find card counters and cheats at the Stratosphere
casino in Las Vegas. He expected it would catch terrorists, if the computer had
a good database to use.
"People use different colored glasses and mustaches and things like
that. They'll grow a beard. And it certainly worked on that," he said. A
major airport could outfit itself with cameras and computer systems at all the
gates for hundreds of thousands of dollars, said Tom Colatosi, Viisage president
and CEO.
His software takes 128 readings of each face and compares the result to a
database.
That would mean searching for individuals, rather than using computers to
find unknowns, which some civil libertarians object to as intrusive. But
Colatosi said those concerns have faded since the World Trade Center bombing.
"I see the airports here in Boston are saying no more curbside check-in,
you can't drive within 300 feet of the door, and all those types of things"
he said. "They are all going to increase the inconvenience for the
traveling public, and none of them would have prevented the hijacking at
Logan."
(C) Reuters Limited 2001.