BANGALORE, INDIA: The debate over the longevity of native software continues. Mozilla, creator of Firefox, claims that its new browser for smartphones will contribute to the death of smartphone app stores.

Scheduled to begin appearing on devices at the end of this year, the Firefox mobile browser, code-named Fennec, will be packed with features to make it the closest thing yet to a real, desktop-class browser. (Wired.com's Mike Calore has a detailed look at Fennec.) Mozilla claims it will have the fastest JavaScript engine of any mobile browser, allowing developers to produce HTML- and JavaScript-coded apps for Fennec rather than for multiple smartphone platforms, such as iPhone OS, Google Android or Windows Mobile.

"In the interim period, apps will be very successful," said Jay Sullivan, vice president of Mozilla's mobile division, in an interview with PC Pro. "Over time, the web will win because it always does."

Web proponents such as Mozilla and Google dream that internet standards will enable any app to run on any device, just as Java proponents touted a "write once, run anywhere" vision in the 1990s. Similarly, Adobe's Flash emerged as a cross-platform environment for creating animations, games and apps for the web. But many consumers and developers have complained that Java and Flash exhibit bugs, performance problems and security vulnerabilities, among other issues. And Java's promises of universality didn't quite work out, because different implementations of the Java virtual machine (not to mention wildly varying hardware capabilities) mean that, even today, Java coders need to rework their apps for each target device.

But web proponents maintain that the wide acceptance of next-generation internet standards, particularly HTML5, will win out where Java failed.

It's a tempting vision. Currently, when deciding whether to buy a Mac or a PC, an Xbox 360 or a PlayStation 3, or an iPhone or a Droid, you need to consider which applications you'll be able to run on each one. If programmers head in the direction of the web, then ideally you'll be able to gain access to any application regardless of the computer or smartphone you own.

Google is attempting to lead the web movement. The search giant is pushing its web-only regime with Chrome OS, its browser-based operating system for netbooks that will run only web applications. Also, in July, Google's engineering vice president and developer evangelist Vic Gundotra said in a conference that mobile app stores have no future.

"Many, many applications can be delivered through the browser and what that does for our costs is stunning," Gundotra was quoted in a Financial Times report. "We believe the web has won and over the next several years, the browser, for economic reasons almost, will become the platform that matters and certainly that's where Google is investing."

But iPhone developers and analysts polled in July by Wired.com explained the problems with current web technologies, and some highlighted the merits of native-app architecture.

Interpet analyst Michael Gartenberg noted that many iPhone apps are a combination of native and web technologies, because many apps download or share data through the internet. He said it's beneficial for the apps to be native, because they're programmed to take full advantage of the iPhone's hardware.

"It's odd that Google feels the need to position as one versus the other," Gartenberg said in July. "That's last century thinking…. It's not about web applications or desktop applications but integrating the cloud into these applications that are on both my phone and the PC. Ultimately, it's about offering the best of both worlds to create the best experience for consumers — not forcing them to choose one or the other."

With Firefox's mobile browser rolling out soon, we have yet to see how consumers and developers react to Mozilla's attempt to spark a web-only exodus. We'll continue examining this topic in the months to come.

Meanwhile, what are your thoughts about the web-versus-native debate? Add your comments, or participate in the poll below. (With Inputs from Wired)

Back to Main Page